Communication and the Law- The Communications Decency Act

WASHINGTON - OCTOBER 06:  Albert Snyder (2nd L...
Image by Getty Images via @daylife

The law has had implications in communication since the advent of the First Amendment right to free speech. Title V of the Telecommunication Act of 1996 also known as the Communications Decency act was brought into being in an effort to regulate and prohibit activities. It was originally intended as a legislative response to the overwhelming number of obscene sites on the Internet. In fact its main goal was to protect children from pornography on the web. Yet in its enactment the law expanded provisions that caused it to also be applicable to obscene and harassing phone calls as well as to adult content on cable television.

This legislation specifically prohibits obscene or harassing utilization of a wide array of telecommunicative devices including the telephone, cable television programming and the Internet for the purpose transmitting, viewing, or accessing pornography. In relation to cable television, it gave permission for the cable broadcast stations to block access to people that weren’t subscribers, and allowed cable stations to have the right to not carry programs they deemed obscene. It also offered protection to internet service providers from any legal consequences as a result of what other people posted on the web- i.e. third party content.

An individual can be held criminally liable for knowingly transmitting patently offensive, indecent or obscene materials over the Internet. This was a highly controversial act that many felt was the governments attempt to censor internet content- however others felt that it was extremely important to make sure that children could have an safe and enjoyable internet experience and that if in the event a child did encounter obscene material that the ISP itself wasn’t held liable. This was viewed as a very important piece of legislation by ISP’s because it provided them with much needed protection from being sued for content they had no control over.

Net Neutrality- What’s it All About

In the 21st century the World Wide Web a.k.a. the Internet is a virtual hub of communication- if you will. Net a neutrality is a movement or principle that seeks to ensure there are no restrictions put in place by an internet service providers, on what an internet users can access online including content, websites, programs, and equipment used to access the web and communicate.

The concern arises from talks about certain about broadband providers to create a tiered system that would change the way individuals’ access and communicate. Currently we all access the Internet at the same level, we all have access to the content on the web that is not legally restricted across the board. Certain institutions are seeking to change that. Instead individuals would be required to pay for certain levels of access. People would have to pay higher amounts of money for access at higher levels. Also certain sites, such as P2P or peer-to-peer sites would be blocked across the board. Access would be more of a fee based service with these with more money having greater access and those with less money being able to access and communicate on a much more restricted level.

Proponents of net neutrality argue that users should be able to have free access to all data, technology, and that without this access; competition and innovation would cease to exist. Opponents of net neutrality argue that people should have the option have a better to have a better Internet; and that allowing people to pay for services at different levels will bring an influx of capital into the Internet will allow for greeter technological innovation. Both sides seem to be operating for the same outcome just thru different modes. One believes it should occur naturally the other via money. For now the Internet remains neutral.